Looking over this thread, it seems there's an unwritten consensus that the food at Obelix is, at the very least, photogenic. Count me in the group that agrees with that but . . .
G Wiv wrote:Enjoyable, if ever so slightly overwrought . . .
I felt similarly at our dinner there earlier this week. In most ways, our meal could be described as flawless and yet . . . for whatever reason, I didn't totally connect with it. I can't say enough about the skillfully prepared, immaculately plated dishes. And service was among the best I've experienced anywhere in town in a long time. Maybe I just need some imperfection to help things to sink in. Okay, there was a bit of that but very little. As I wrote above, the meal was just about flawless. Here's a rundown, with descriptions lifted directly from the menu . . .
EpiThis was actually one of the few weak links. This bread was pretty flavorless. However, it was not an omen of things to come.
Pate En Croute -
Wild Boar, Duck, Pistachio, Foie Gras, Housemade Pastry DoughRich, unctuous and satisfying.
Gougeres -
Raclette Mornay, TruffleLoved the lightly crispy exteriors and the intense, pungent filling.
Macaron Au Foie Gras -
Foie Gras Mousse, Date JamReally a cool concept. Loved the richness of the foie, and contrast in textures but in the end, it was too sweet a bite for me. My 2 companions absolutely loved them.
Soupe A' L'Oignon Gratinee -
French Onion Soup, Beef Broth, Swiss Cheese, CroutonsHands down one of the best -- if not the best -- versions I've ever had. So deeply flavorful and the cheese stayed gooey and runny until the very end, never seizing up.
Escargots A' La Bourguignonne -
Snails, Garlic, ParsleyHerbaceous, rich and brightly flavorful.
Next up, sides and mains . . .
Broccolini -
with Al Pastor Hollandaise, BreadcrumbsAn excellent prep. Good char, tender but not mushy and a great sauce to bring it all home.
Frites -
with garlic aioliWay better than they looked. Light and crispy until the very end.
Ratatouille Pithivier -
Eggplant, Zucchini, Bell Peppers, Rainbow Chard, Humboldt Fog Goat Cheese, Sauce Tomate, Pâte BriséeEnjoyed this quite a bit, though, I wish the veg filling had been a little more concentrated in flavor. But inside that wonderful pâte brisée, if they cooked any longer, the pastry would have burnt. As it was, those veg were just a bit too subtle for me.
Black Cod -
Grilled Bok Choy, Ube Purée, Pickled Pearl Onion, Soy Glazed Mushrooms, Green CurryPerfectly prepared with moist, tender flesh and a perfectly crispy skin. Loved the way pickled onions provided pops of contrast in both flavor and texture.
10-Day Dry-Aged Duck Breast -
Crépinette De Canard, Sunflower Miso, Grapes, Salsify, Grape GastriqueGreat stuff here. Breast was cooked perfectly and the decadent crepinette was pure pleasure.
We were pretty darned full -- hadn't even finished what we'd ordered so far -- but we wanted to try one dessert to finish off our meal. Honestly, the selection wasn't enticing to me. When it comes to dessert, I'm very much a 'right down the middle of the fairway' guy and there was none of that to be had here. Each selection had what I consider to be a deal-breaker component but I could also tell, just from reading Pastry Chef Antonio Incandela's menu (and experiencing his many touches throughout the dinner menu), that these were most likely some world-class desserts. 'High-wire act' is the term that comes to mind. We opted for the Baked Alaska . . .
Baked Alaska -
Gooey butter cake, Chicago mix popcorn, truffle, sweet corn ice creamI don't remember the liquor with which this was flambeed but it certainly was a thrilling production.
Baked AlaskaJust look at this precisely prepared and obviously well-considered dessert. Personally, I thought the truffle was a major distraction and I didn't love the sweet corn ice cream either. And yet, I know this dessert was something truly special. It just wasn't for me.
So, would I recommend Obelix? Absolutely. But will I be rushing back? Probably not. I have a lot of respect for the skill and effort that were clearly put into every facet of our meal. The space is inviting, comfortable and conversation-friendly. Service was warm, knowledgeable and professional. The place didn't feel stodgy, staid or haughty in any way. It was all completely inviting. I'm going to chalk up my curious lack of enthusiasm to my ever-evolving tastes and preferences. That said, it's clear that this is some top line cuisine prepared and served by talented and dedicated professionals in a completely inviting setting. Not inexpensive but a relative value given the quality here. Special occasion? Yep, this is the place.
=R=
Same planet, different world