LTHForum.com

I don't know how much more can be said about this relatively recent addition to the Chicago pizza scene.

After years of complaining about the pizza available in Chicago, finally discovering Chicago-style thin crust stalwarts like Marie's and Vito & Nick's, I leave at the dawn of a Chicago pizza renaissance.

Coalfire immediately vaulted into my top 2 Chicago pizza joints. I love the laid-back atmosphere. I like the BYOB, meaning two can eat for under $25 with a bottle of wine. Or six can down a fifth of bourbon and about 8 pizzas. I love the neighborhood they opened in, where I can enjoy a healthy walk from our River North office, revealing much of Chicago's diversity over a mile or two, and the usual subsequent walk up to the Matchbox.

Most of the Coalfire discussion has happened in one place:

http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?t=12492

But it pops up elsewhere too, suggesting it's become a standard/favorite of many posters:

http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=147493#147493
http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=146521#146521
http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=138956#138956
http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=142876#142876

And the crush with which LTHers descended upon the place in its early days has been well-documented in other media as well.

There have been a few service complaints, but it seems that was mostly a by-product of said crush.

New or no, Coalfire seems like a no-brainer to me. I've been to Chicago just twice since Coalfire opened, and I've been to Coalfire both times. I look forward to my next trip.

Coalfire
1321 W. Grand Ave.
312-226-2625
Closed Monday

I love Coalfire, have been several times, and considered nominating it. But after LTH descended upon them in a crush on day 3, and then some (a limited few) complained online about the restaurant not being able to handle the the crush caused by LTH, I thought they might be inclined to take the GNR and tell us to put it where the sun don't shine.

That's not saying I don't think they deserve one; any reservations I'd have would be that it might be a little premature (they've not been open long) and it might be good to let any bad feelings dissipate.

I've only been there once, but I felt like there was one really good pizza (the one with Bari sausage) and a couple of others that I didn't like nearly so well, though even so they were obviously better than at least 70% of the generi-pizza sold by the slice around town. I need to go again, although it's hard for me to do so because I end up passing half the woodfired pizzas in town on my way.

My main impression from the white, New Haven-style pizza was, oh good, now we have one, so people can stop asking where to get one. But I'm not sure I need to try it ever again, or at least again this decade. (But then, I wasn't walking around thinking Chicago pizza was broken before Spacca Napoli opened, either. I thought it was in pretty damn good shape, frankly...)

Anyway, I lean a little toward the premature side, also. Or maybe it's not premature any more, but I haven't been, so I don't know. Has the menu evolved? Has its pizza hand developed? Has its promise been fully realized?

Aaron,

I heartily second Coalfire for a GNR. I've been 5-6 times, each time thoroughly enjoying what, in my opinion, is one of the top pizzas available in Chicagoland.

Enjoy,
Gary

Which one?

I don't know which Gary is eating, but as I mentioned to Mike at the picnic, my perfect pizza is the 'white', PLUS the toppings from the 'sausage.' New Haven purists will have my head, and I get raised eyebrows at the counter for this, but the garlic-and-basil-prepared dough with the more interesting cheese, under red sauce and Bari sausage, is pure heaven.

I also love the Fiorentino, which tastes just like the brick oven versions on the Via Della Scala and transports me to two autumn conferences at the Fortezza da Basso. In my continuing effort to make the most obscure analogies possible, there is a wonderful Commodore 64 game called Blue Max:

http://c64s.com/game/406/blue_max/

When your WWI-era biplane crashes, you see a perfect little burnt-out cinder impression on the ground. That's exactly what happens to the salami on the CoalFire Fiorentino; it's ex-salami, a burnt offering, a remembrance of lunchmeats past.

You mean like do I order the exact same pizza every time?

I've never been with less than 3 other people, couple of times 6 or 8, and we tend to order rounds of pizza. If I had to single out one Coalfire pizza I've had, and it would be a close call, I'd go with a nicely blistered anchovy and sausage Steve Z ordered one evening.

I'm also quite partial to the White Pizza.

Enjoy,
Gary

Another link:

http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?p=150434#150434

I completely agree with this nomination. Coalfire has managed to bridge the gap between the foldable New York style and more traditional Chicago thin crust pizza and have completely won me over, despite being a die hard Chicago pizza snob. Great crust, great ingredients and a pizziolo who really knows his way around the coal/wood fired oven. Early service issues seem to have vanished for the most part. I say Coalfire = yes to a GNR.

This restaurant is currently up for GNR renewal. Please post your comments below.

Thanks,

=R=
for the GNRs

I'll freely admit that I'm not a deep-dish guy at all - I'm not originally from here and I just don't "get it" - so let that be known as background when I say that Coalfire is my favorite pizza in town. My most recent visit included (among other pizzas ordered) the waitress' recommendation of sausage, hot sopressata and fresh mozzarella - wow!

I've simply never had a dud - the pizzas always strike my perfect balance of quality toppings, appropriate levels of cheese and tangy sauce, and of course the thin chewy crust with just the right amount of char.

-Dan

What I said two posts up back in 2007 still rings true for me today. A big YES for renewal.

LTH,

I've been to Coalfire a dozen or more times since they were awarded a GNR in '07 and have come to appreciate the care and thought they put into the pizza, not to mention the deliciousness factor, to an even greater degree.

Support for GNR renewal from this pizza lover.

Enjoy,
Gary

I also suppurt this GNR renewal, it's in my neighborhood and I'm happy about it. I will have to admit, I do go less frequently now that it is not BYOB. Two pizzas and a bottle of wine isn't as cheap as it used to be. And with the price being what it is, I tend to go to places I can have a few choices on the menu for the same price. But, I do love the coalfire style of pizza and it's my go to place.

The only coal-fired pizza oven in Chicago is merely one aspect of the great pizza turned out here. High quality toppings, sublime cheeses and an artisanal aesthetic that is hard to find in this city of overloaded pizzas, are the rest of the equation. I only wish it were open for lunch because I'd be able to eat there much more frequently if it were. Still, I love Coalfire and I feel that we're lucky to have it, especially in this town where good pizza is ubiquitous but great pizza is still a somewhat rare commodity. Coalfire produces a distinctive, excellent product. I say yes on renewal.

=R=

Technically untrue; D'Amato's, the other coal oven baker in town, does make Sicilian-style sheet pizza.

But we know what you mean...

Mea culpa. I always think of D'Amato's strictly as a bread bakery, even though I know that's not the case.

=R=

More on Coalfire:

viewtopic.php?p=174744#p174744
viewtopic.php?p=224882#p224882
viewtopic.php?p=171516#p171516

A great big "yes" for renewal. I'm lucky in that Coalfire is my neighborhood pizza place; I usually get it to-go and have had it probably two dozen times since it was awarded the GNR. It's still great and unique pizza - where else can you get pizza like this with that signature coal-fired char? This is my favorite pizza in the city.

A recent picture of the sausage: